Saturday, 26 March 2011

WELSH MADNESS AND BABY BOOMING

I am besieged by official letters telling me to ‘ACT NOW!” Usually in capitals to increase the urgency and sometimes in very large envelopes - I suppose to make them seem more important. One weighed so much that I fear the spine of poor Annie, our ever cheerful post-lady, will be lop-sided ever after. Despite this she still smiled as she handed over my census form.

Incidentally, have you noticed how the majority of postmen (both male and female) are happy? Considering their lot - out in all weathers, carrying heavy loads, working to deadlines, awful management, poor pay - you’d think they'd be all as miserable as sin and only stay in the job a couple of weeks before exclaiming ‘blow this for a game of soldiers.’ But no, they go on and on. Smiling like the sun, even in the rain, and always ready to offer up those little courtesies that make life bearable.

Of course they complain - but they do so happily. Very few are sour and po-faced. So what is it about the postman’s lot? They are all very fit and I suppose that helps and seeing the rest of the world at seven o’clock in the morning must give you a comforting feeling of moral superiority.

But back to ‘ACT NOW.’ The heavyweight census form came in separate booklets in English and Welsh. Now I have nothing against the Welsh language. I even spent two years learning some of it at evening classes and I once played the Wicked Witch of the West in a performance of Snow White in some learners’ pantomime. I can still sing ‘Hi Ho, it’s off to work we go’ in Welsh (Hi Ho, Hi He, I ffordd y’r gwaith a’r ni). I have given a Welsh culture class at a school in Norway and had the students performing in Welsh and acting out a version of that great rugby song, ‘Sospan Fach.’ (Which means - and not everyone even in Wales knows this - ‘Small Saucepan’)

So I am not, you see, anti-Welsh. I have done my bit for the language. But I am certainly not up to completing my census in Welsh. Or any other form for that matter.

I shudder to think what it costs to send a Welsh Language census form to the ninety per cent of the population (and probably more) who will choose to respond in English. For many Welsh speakers will still choose to use the English version. More than two and a half million twenty-page booklets will go straight in the bin. All in the name of political correctness. The cost of translation into Welsh is appreciable and the cost of printing in Welsh is also elevated because most printers do not speak the language. But this is what the Welsh Language Act decrees.

It is madness. Why can we not opt how we wish to receive our government communications? When I go to a cashpoint the machine asks me, thoughtfully, in which language it should address me. Besides English and Welsh it offers other choices: French for instance, or German. So why not the government?

It would be a simple matter to register a preference. It could be done at the same time as the electoral register update? “Do you wish us to communicate with your household in: English only, Welsh only, or English and Welsh?” And we could tick the appropriate box. If there was doubt then the default position would be English and Welsh.

Still, now that I come to think of it, we might then demand another choice entirely. We might demand a form in English, properly thought through, and not in some form of hurry-up officialese.

For instance, seeing the words ‘ACT NOW’ you could be excused for filling in the form then and there and posting it off. Instead the small print says to complete the form on 28th March. But even acting on 28th March is wrong because the forms asks for details of people staying overnight on 28th March. Which means (because you never know who might turn up on your doorstep at two minutes to midnight, do you?) that it is impossible to complete the form accurately until 29th March.

Sometimes I’m glad I’m a baby-boomer and therefore on my way out. Responding to other requests to ‘ACT NOW,’ I claimed two pensions this week, one from the government (another binned booklet in Welsh) and one from a provider of ‘financial services.’ Or in my case disservices. Had I only listened to my inner self and put the money under my mattress I’m sure I couldn’t have done worse. Still I have ordered a small annuity and had it indexed. If now I can only manage to live until I'm 120 I feel sure I can extract my revenge.

11 comments:

Pondside said...

Yes, Fennie - live to 120 and thumb your nose at the financial planners!
Regarding the English/Welsh forms - that's a way of life here. Every last piece of paper, advertising - anything at all - must be translated to French at huge delay and cost.

Norma Murray said...

We filled in the wretched thing weeks ago and posted it off - I doubt if we'll get another because they got it back too early...But then again we might.
I know what you mean about post 'people' being a cheerful bunch.As I child I remember our postie well. He was known by all the locals as 'Sunny Jim'. He scandalised my mother by swinging by one hand on our porch. But there again, she'd led a sheltered life.

Elizabeth Musgrave said...

I like your idea of choosing how you wish to be communicated with. I like getting English and Welsh because, as a Welsh learner (3 years down, 39 and a half to go to fluency) I like the chance to try to understand. But it can't be the best way of managing things to send both language versions to everyone. Suggest it. I'll second you. If you can work out who to suggest it to.

Frances said...

Fennie, I am glad to be just a month or so too old to be an official baby boomer. It gives me that welcome distance to view most of the folks who truly are my contemporaries.

We get lots of official docs in New York printed in several languages, usually English and Spanish, but some others are often included.

I also love to try to translate various official signs and advertisements I see on my daily travels on the New York City subway system.

But I digress. Let me agree with you about the shame of waste that could be avoided. Will it ever be avoided? Doubt it.

xo

Fennie said...

Pondside: I suppose when you consider what happens here is only a fraction of what happens around the world, we can begin to appreciate the craziness of it all. Just let the people choose.

Norma: Yes, they are in a class all of their own for cheerfulness and good humour. Wish they would sell it along with the stamps.

Elizabethm: I have suggested it but of course the stock answer is that this is what the WLA decrees and it is seriously politically incorrect to suggest what I am suggesting.

Frances: I do the same as you with the street and other signs. How many people speak Spanish in New York? Is it the major tongue (after English) 20%?

mountainear said...

I'd like to be asked how I would like my official correspondence too - mainly to see an end to the waste of that mountain of superfluous paper. Our Welsh bits go straight to the recycling I'm afraid.

I'm all for retaining national identity and certainly respect Welsh pride in Wales but most of this excess paper is being financed by the tax payer. I might be wrong but private enterprise seems to take a much more pragmatic approach - perhaps with its eye more firmly fixed on the bottom line.

I'll settle for my money going towards filling a few holes in the road.

Grumble, grumble ....

Posie said...

Fennie my friend filled hers in a couple of weeks early and posted it off before she realised it was to be filled in at a later date.Mine seemed to take forever to fill in..all those lodgers haha!!Here, we are fighting for the survival of the Gaelic language, part of our children's heritage which is threatening to die out, so I do feel bilingual forms are important, especially when you consider most forms are multi lingual with no mention of the welsh or Gaelic languages, but with languages from miles away.

Vagabonde said...

There is so much waste everywhere. I was reading that the US Congress prints everything that is said there – volumes and volumes. It is also on line so no one reads the volumes. They go directly into the dump.

Kath said...

Fennie, I am 100% with you on how wasteful it was to receive two census forms, one in Welsh and the other in English. It was doubly so here, as I completed our census online!

I had to laugh at your reaction to demands to ACT NOW and you're so right that you couldn't complete the Census form until Monday. You never know who might have knocked the door late at night...*sigh*

Anonymous said...

I did the census online in the end. I know if I had tried the paper version it would have ended up screwed up and thrown across the room. My laptop is more valuable.

BTW You have a won an award!! I’m passing the LIEBSTER award on to you, if you’d like to take a wee look on my page hope you don’t mind!
Sorry there's no real prize but have some love!

ps just in case you wonder I'm a lurker. I read but don't normally post

lizzie said...

I see that you've decided to leave the Purple site- so thought I'd add my comment here re Welshness etc.I think one of the saddest things I've come across is my Welsh Great grandmother putting English as her first language on a cencus form at the turn of the last century. In fact she spoke and thought in welsh.