Saturday, 29 September 2012

HOMEOPATHY AND BILL

Samuel Hahnemann, Founder of Homeopathy
My daughter suggested I go to see the homeopath who she had gone to see when little Theo had a recalcitrant cough that proved resistant to normal medicine. The homeopath (Bill) gave her some tablets which worked wonders and so she had great faith in him and told me to go along in turn instead of complaining endlessly about my own digestion, a malady which for decades now has baffled medical science and kept me uncomfortably awake at nights.

Of course I was sceptical.  But Bill said he welcomed sceptics and I have to confess that the consultation was most interesting and proved a valuable experience. We talked for almost an hour and a half while Bill made copious notes.  Later I felt that just talking about the problem had been therapeutic for I then began to see that all my symptoms seemed to be connected to some underlying nervous or emotional reaction.  Stress in other words.  And driving and striving, too hard. I must learn to be calmer, I concluded, though Bill didn't say this himself.  The world is quite capable of getting on without me.

At the end of the session he gave me three minute white pills to take, then and there, which would, he said, 'reset' my digestive system. They tasted like sugar.  He said the active ingredient in them belonged to the same plant family whose fossilised remains make up the South Wales coal field.  And he invited me back in six weeks to see whether anything has changed.

While I found the consultation therapeutic in some psychological sense,  I simply cannot believe the claims that highly dilute medicines work.  We are talking of dilutions as weak as a pinch of salt in the Atlantic ocean in some cases, according to the research I have looked at.  Still, I'd rather have three little pills that last six weeks than to have take half a dozen prescription medicines everyday - a separate medicine for each symptomatic condition - whose effects on each other in combination have never been tested.  Maybe that is the reason why homeopathic remedies are so dilute - just so they won't (can't) do you any harm.  Meanwhile you benefit from a sympathetic ear and a chance to relate all the symptoms to one another and to your lifestyle.

We also spent a little time discussing something that has always interested me: the difference between a living and a dead body. What happens at death? What changes biochemically? One moment the life force is there; the next it isn't.  One moment a person or animal is patently alive, the next it is dead.  So what changes? What has happened? And couldn't whatever has happened be reversed before the body begins to rot?  This life force, Bill reckons, courses through us all and through every part of us; sometimes, and in some places, it is stronger than others. Sometimes it becomes blocked or obstructed. Sometimes it requires re-setting. This, he reckoned, he had just done.

I am not persuaded.  I feel rather that he has allowed me to see for myself what I need to do to change things - although I am not at all sure that I know what I should be doing, moment by moment, to make this change.  I agree with him about the idea of a life force and of this becoming obstructed.  I think this is the basis of several healing methods.  And, as is well known, certain people, whatever kind of medicine they practice, are just 'healers:' that is they have a beneficial effect on sick people just by being with them. How this works I cannot even begin to guess.  But I should describe Bill as one of those 'healers.'

I should call him, he said, should there be any sudden changes, but I suspect there won't be.  I cannot imagine how one can have an allergic reaction to a homeopathic medicine.  But I do feel that he achieved something and that if I can only remember the feeling of calmness that he was able to engender then I shall improve. I was pleased anyway when I wrote the cheque for his fee for I thought it money well spent.

The test will come in six weeks time. Whether by then I will have learned to divert a part of my life force towards my liver and away from silly and stressful things, I do not know.  Is writing a blog stressful? Am I holding up my hand and shouting 'me too!' in a vain attempt to find some echo in the ether that tells me I exist and that I am important?  I am sure that was the case once.  Now, well, I think I can honestly say that I am writing this for myself. If anyone is amused by what I write that is fine.  If not, no matter.  It is not time wasted.  The sun is shining and I shall enjoy the day.  Light a candle, smile and enjoy a glass of wine.  Eat a square of dark chocolate and look at some flowers and do whatever work requires to be done today.

The picture, courtesy of Wikipedia is of Samuel Hahnemann (1755-1843), the acknowledged founder of homeopathy. As he lived to the ripe old age of 88 at a time when most people were lucky to live half that time, the proof of his pudding can be seen perhaps in his longevity. 

9 comments:

Pondside said...

I have no experience with homeopathy or naturpathy, but there is a lot of anecdotal evidence around to make me think that it can be as efficacious as what we think of as 'normal' medicine. I'd tend to agree with you that this was money well-spent if you came away with a feeling of calm. If you can find that calm again when stress threatens your head and your digestion, then I'd consider that it worked.

mountainear said...

I'm a bit sceptical too - or was until my neighbour (who goes in for all sorts of 'alternative' therapies and listens to a crystal) - invited me to take my rather excitable dog for a consultation with the Homeopathist who had come to treat her horses. Now as far as I know animals don,t do sceptical. They just react.

Wilson was offered very dilute solutions of various remedies - some he backed away from, others he sniffed and one he lapped at with enthusiasm. He left that consultation very chilled. Can't say it had a lasting effect though!

I agree that talking can be very therapeutic and hope the session worked for you - let us know how the next appointment goes.

Frances said...

Fennie, I will join Pondside and mountaineer in having no personal experience with alternative medicines, though knowing folks who truly find homeopathy very helpful.

It seems good that you followed up on your daughter's suggestion, and that so far the session with Bill has proved beneficial.

May the calm spread many days, weeks, months, years into the future. xo

Exmoorjane said...

Great post. My mother was a homoeopath and so I grew up with a very cynical and sceptical attitude! But...it often works. Why? Who knows. Maybe, as you say, the person is simply a healer, or the emotional exchange is therapeutic or maybe, just maybe, there is an energy in the pill that reacts with our own bioenergy. But, like Felicity, I've seen it work with animals. Monty, the boxer, had an extra six months of good quality life thanks to a homoeopath who stopped his bleeding within seconds. My old GP used to use it alongside 'normal' medicine and James never had antibiotics for ear infections when little - just pulsatilla - which sorted it every time. Yet, if he felt one of us needed a 'medical' intervention, he'd prescribe that. And that, to me, is how medicine should be - integrated... I could go on for hours but suffice to say, I hope your digestion sorts itself...with or without the pills. :)

Anonymous said...

Well I was also somewhat surprised when it worked for me... at the very least it seems to do no harm and at the very best, a whole new you.... I use it in an integrated way it has to be said as I have a GP who does both! ... Heather

Fennie said...

Pondside, Ah! But that's the difficult bit. You can see you need to get from A to B, but it's not easy finding a route.

Mountainear, that is most interesting! There seems to be a well-attested body of evidence that homeopathy works on animals - see Jane's post below. Maybe Wilson needs some of the remedy everyday.

Frances - you always seem a calm person and controlled too. Maybe you are taking something special? maybe you have a secret?

Jane - thanks for your good wishes. Yes, I hope so do. I do believe that we humans have an operating system much like a computer operating system. Something that lives between us and the world and which interprets the world to us. This determines whether certain events trigger an emotional reaction or something else. If you are frightened of house spiders or mice here is an example of a faulty operating system giving you an emotional reaction instead of a rational one.
Too many emotional reactions are bad for the nerves.

Heather, I am glad to hear that like Jane you have a GP that does both. I've always found GP's rather pushed for time, or they think I am making something up. One GP did tell me to meditate and set up a meditation class. I give her full marks for that.




Catherine said...

I am so pleased you are trying homeopathy, Fennie. It is a subject very close to my heart as I am almost two years into a four year course, training to become a homeopath.

It is a very interesting and complex system of health care and deserves greater recognition as it is a huge force for healing. Let us know how things progress.

Fennie said...

Marianne, Watch this space, as they say. Thus far nothing has happened. But I know what I have to do to start something happening if you see what I mean. And that something lies in my brain. Thanks for looking in. Good luck with your own training.

Cait O'Connor said...

I would love to know how you are getting on with the homeopathic remedies. I know it takes a long time. I do agree about the life force energy blockage thing and believe that stress is the cause of most (but not all) our ills.